ChatGPT vs. Doctors: Can You Tell the Difference?

Published On Sat May 13 2023
ChatGPT vs. Doctors: Can You Tell the Difference?

Quiz—Can You Tell the Difference Between ChatGPT and a Doctor?

Are you ready to put your medical knowledge to the test and see if you can tell the difference between ChatGPT and a real doctor? A recent study published in JAMA Internal Medicine revealed that an AI language model can answer medical questions as accurately as the human doctors. The study compared the responses from r/AskDocs on Reddit and found that ChatGPT was rated higher in terms of quality and empathy than human doctors.

But what would happen if both, ChatGPT and human doctors, answered the same questions? In this quiz, we will show you ten real examples from the study, and you have to guess whether the answer was written by a doctor or ChatGPT.

Quiz Questions

  1. Question: My stomach hurts, and I feel bloated. What should I do?
  2. Answer: This one was written an actual human doctor.

  3. Question: Can I use sunscreen every day to protect my skin?
  4. Answer: This was written by your friend ChatGPT.

  5. Question: What can I do to reduce my fever?
  6. Answer: It’s another response from ChatGPT.

  7. Question: My throat is sore, and I have a fever. Do I have strep throat?
  8. Answer: A real live doctor wrote this, bro.

  9. Question: Is there a cure for HIV?
  10. Answer: It’s a message from Dr. AI.

  11. Question: What is the treatment for pneumonia?
  12. Answer: This one is straight from a (human) doctor’s mouth.

  13. Question: How long after exposure to the flu do symptoms appear?
  14. Answer: This detailed medical advice comes from ChatGPT.

  15. Question: Can I get pregnant while on birth control?
  16. Answer: That’s a real surgeon talking.

  17. Question: Can a person die from a heart attack?
  18. Answer: This one’s ChatGPT.

  19. Question: What are the symptoms of depression?
  20. Answer: This doctor talks like a robot, but they are, in fact, an actual person.

How did you do? Were you able to tell the difference between ChatGPT and a doctor's response? While AI language models continue to improve, it's essential to remember that they lack the personal touch and empathy that only human doctors can provide. It's unlikely that AI will replace doctors anytime soon, but it does present an exciting opportunity to improve healthcare and provide patients with better access to medical information.