Uncovering the Battle: Canadian Publishers vs. OpenAI

Canadian Publishers Sue OpenAI; ChatGPT Accuracy Criticized in ...

Last week’s flurry of AI-based publishing stories—from Microsoft to Spines—left many of us somewhat breathless. Maybe it’s a sign of a quieter week ahead that I can start with a round-up of stories. ALLi News Editor, Dan Holloway

OpenAI Faces Lawsuit from Canadian Publishers

First, we have a familiar story from the publishing and AI battleground: OpenAI is facing a lawsuit. This time the legal action comes from Canadian publishers—specifically, Canadian news publishers—who claim OpenAI has made neither payment nor an offer of payment in return for scraping (or, as OpenAI puts it, “using”) their creative output. OpenAI has already signed many deals with publishing companies, which has also been contentious.

As an article reproduced by Publishers Weekly from their daily reportage on Frankfurt points out, OpenAI can afford to. Their latest $6 billion raise values the company at $157 billion. Their revenues for this year are projected to be $3.7 billion—approximately three-quarters those of publishing giant Penguin Random House, with no end to the growth in sight.

AI's Impact on the Publishing Industry

The most interesting—or depressing, depending on your perspective—part of that same article is Thad McIlroy’s observation analyzing a database of publishing industry startups. In the past two years, there have been 320 of them, almost all connected in some way to AI.

ChatGPT Accuracy Criticized

We end by circling back to journalism and ChatGPT. A new study has found that the platform’s representation of publishers’ material remains alarmingly prone to inaccuracy. This inaccurate tendency seems to bear little relation to whether the source material comes from a publisher with a license agreement or one whose material has been scraped.

If you’re an ALLi member, head over to the SelfPubConnect forum for support from our experienced community of indie authors, advisors, and our own ALLi team. Non-members looking for more information can search our extensive archive of blog posts and podcast episodes packed with tips and advice at ALLi's Self-Publishing Advice Center.