I tested Siri against Gemini and Bixby in 25 challenges, and one ...
With rumors of Apple's Siri voice assistant potentially receiving an upgrade at WWDC 2024, I decided to compare Siri against other voice assistants to see how it measures up. Siri, a familiar name in the world of voice assistants, has evolved significantly since its inception as an app in 2010. Over the years, Siri has become an integral part of iOS devices, offering various functionalities beyond just providing weather updates or setting timers.
One of Siri's key strengths is its ability to control different features on your phone and assist with tasks like finding your Apple Watch or even helping you locate your parked car. It has grown to encompass a broader range of capabilities, such as managing home devices and setting reminders, making it a versatile voice assistant.
Bixby: The Samsung Contender
On the other hand, Samsung introduced Bixby in 2017, replacing its previous S Voice assistant. Bixby was positioned as a comprehensive interface that aimed to integrate seamlessly with various Samsung products, spanning from smartphones to home appliances. While Bixby may not operate on a large language model (LLM) like some other AI assistants, it has been continually enhanced to deliver a better user experience.
Introducing Gemini by Google
For users seeking an alternative voice assistant, Google's Gemini offers a compelling option. Gemini, a product of Google's LLM technology, provides an advanced AI experience on Android devices. By leveraging Google's extensive suite of applications and services, Gemini aims to surpass its predecessor, Google Assistant, in performance and functionality.
Comparing Performance: Siri, Bixby, and Gemini
In a head-to-head comparison, I tested Siri, Bixby, and Gemini on flagship devices from Apple, Samsung, and Google. Through a series of 25 tasks designed to evaluate their capabilities, I assessed the performance of each voice assistant.
While Siri demonstrated proficiency in completing 13 tasks successfully, it fell short on seven occasions, providing inaccurate responses or failing to understand requests. Notably, Siri struggled with specific commands that Bixby and Gemini handled with ease.
One standout feature of Bixby was its ability to understand nuanced commands and deliver accurate results. For instance, when asked to initiate screen recording, Bixby executed the task promptly, surpassing Siri and Gemini in this aspect.
Similarly, Bixby's translation capabilities stood out as it seamlessly facilitated language translations through intuitive interactions. In contrast, Siri and Gemini faced challenges in executing similar translation tasks effectively.
Conclusion
As AI assistants like Siri, Bixby, and Gemini continue to evolve, the competition intensifies, driving innovation and improvements in user experiences. While each voice assistant has its strengths and weaknesses, Bixby emerged as a strong competitor, showcasing advanced functionalities and intuitive responses that set it apart from its counterparts.
Whether you prioritize seamless integration with Samsung devices, Google's cutting-edge AI technology, or Apple's familiar voice assistant, the choice ultimately hinges on your preferences and usage requirements.
