Is Apple Intelligence Smarter Than ChatGPT?
An iPhone owner recently tested out Apple Intelligence, the latest artificial intelligence technology from Apple, on the company’s newest operating systems: iOS 18.1, iPadOS 18.1, and macOS Sequoia 15.1. This new AI offers a range of features including advanced writing tools, email and text summaries, and enhancements to the Photo app.
New Features
One of the key features of Apple Intelligence is its new writing and texting capabilities, allowing users to interact with Siri through audio conversations that are instantly transcribed. Users can also conveniently access message and email details directly from their lock screens.
/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/25485545/lcimg_ca61fcb8_ae16_4dcb_8b5a_e5ca6510cfad.jpeg)
Despite the innovative features, some users have expressed concerns about the overall functionality of Apple Intelligence. A TikTok user by the name of Bhdben shared his experience with the system, highlighting certain shortcomings.
Issues with Apple Intelligence
Bhdben discovered that Apple Intelligence provided a misleading summary of a series of text messages he received. The summary indicated a potential house flooding situation, causing confusion and alarm. However, upon reviewing the actual text messages, Bhdben realized that the summary was inaccurate and the situation was not as dire as portrayed.
Professional critics have also raised similar concerns about the new message summaries. The New York Times Wirecutter described the features as "mostly unremarkable" and criticized the notification summaries as "extraneous" and "occasionally hilarious." CNET, in its review, mentioned that the new AI from Apple was "sometimes useful, sometimes amusing."
Comparing Summaries
To further evaluate the accuracy of Apple Intelligence, Bhdben compared its summary with that of ChatGPT. The summary generated by ChatGPT provided a more precise reflection of the text messages, leading Bhdben to conclude that ChatGPT's summary was superior to Apple Intelligence's.
Amidst these evaluations, users have shared similar disappointing experiences with the new feature, citing issues with the accuracy of the summaries provided.
Conclusion
As Apple continues to refine its artificial intelligence technology, feedback from users like Bhdben sheds light on areas for improvement. While Apple Intelligence offers innovative features, the accuracy and reliability of its summaries are crucial for user satisfaction and trust in AI-driven interactions.
It's evident that the comparison between Apple Intelligence and ChatGPT raises questions about the level of intelligence and accuracy offered by these AI technologies. As users navigate the evolving landscape of artificial intelligence, the quest for smarter and more reliable AI solutions continues.
For more information on the features of Apple Intelligence, you can visit The New York Times Wirecutter and CNET.
